I have tried both, at the moment subsonic is the most ideal solution in my situation, but there are many nice things around...
Some requests:
- Get album art, fan art, biography ... from last.fm and other sources.
- Upnp use the art to have a nice living room experience with your htpc (make upnp work well first)
- Make SS watch changes in folders and rescan only the changed part when changes are made.
- Combine multiple server libraries in one instance.
- Mysql support
- Decent web-ui, take a look at plex for instance.
- ACL. Set per user directory access..
- Maybe focus only on music, because you can not do all the things at once??
Let the community be part of the development to speed up the process a bit.. There are so many people with great skills and ideas, so why not make it a team-effort...?
It's not all feature requests
Some things I love about SS:
- Easy to use Webui.
- Keep my folder / file based structure for presenting music...
- Transcoding
- Wide variety of apps. (note that the iSub app is still up to date, but this will change and there is no such alternative on iOS)
- Stability, when running it on tomcat it keeps running for months... (few problems with jetty in the past here)
Keep up the good work!