"Port forwarding disabled" No idea why

[SheepCloner]

I set up Subsonic exactly as described in the instructions. I set a static ip address and forwarded ports 80 and 4040. It was working flawlessly on my laptop, computer at work, Android phone, etc. Then I tried showing it off on Sunday using my phone and I couldn't connect. When I got home, it worked on my Android phone again and dismissed it as a fluke. Now I cannot connect.

In the settings menu/network I am able to have subsonic automatically configure my router. This works for Subsonic, but kills my ability to connect to the internet otherwise. When I deselect this option it says, "port forwarding disabled" Underneath is states "STATUS: xxxxxx.subsonic.org responded successfully.

I have not donated, but I have until the 28th until the trial expires.

I tried with firewalls off and got the same result.

I have verified that ports 80 and 4040 are open.

Any thoughts/ideas/ or comments are appreciated! Thanks!