by fermunky » Fri Feb 12, 2010 9:15 pm
Good news:
Got it working. Long story short, my router was doing something goofy with the port forwarding. Not sure exactly what the problem was, but all I did was go in and completely remove the forwarding for it, removed some other antiquated forwards still there, saved it, then went back and re-added, restarted the subsonic server for good measure, and boom, it worked. Really weird.
So, for those with a similar issue, instead of just trying to change the port being forwarded, try removing it totally, then re-adding the forwarding.